Friday, March 5, 2010

The murder of Hamas leader Al-Mabhouh in Dubai. Another STRATFOR analysis

The recent murder of Hamas' No.1 arms supply procurer/manager, Al-Mabhouh, was only minor news to start with. I don't think there is anyone at all knowledgeable about covert operations or the situation in Gaza who didn't immediately know that there was only ever 1 outfit that would be able and willing to perform such a brazen assassination: Israel's Mossad.

Even if there had been no evidence at all, that much was obvious.

But I must admit, Dubai have been exceptionally good at pursuing the story, publishing hard evidence, and controlling the new cycle by periodically releasing information. The most interesting things from my point of view have been:

1/ How a system of CCTV in an urban environment, combined with the 1000's of tiny electronic trails we all leave as we conduct our daily lives, make it trivial for a modern police/intelligence force to track us, learn a scary amount about us, and monitor what we do. Jack Bauer of 24 fame would be proud (well, except it was all after the fact). That Dubai are releasing this capability so blatantly is a bit reactionary. Usually a good intelligence outfit conceals this sort of stuff.

2/ How pissed off Dubai is that it was done on their patch. Following the assassination (by gun-fire in the open, in a parking lot in Jumeira) of the Chechen ex-rebel leader last year, Dubai Inc. is super pissed off at being shown to be a bit of a pussy and not a safe place for terrorists and arms dealers. Being a haven for those who are rich but wanted criminals or political fugatives, on the run from their home countries [Iran, Iraq, Sudan, Russia, Chechniya, Egypt, Pakistan ...], as well as a great place to do all sorts of shady deals between Iranians and others, has lately been a minor business model for the nation-state. Money laundering controls are famously lax if the price is right.

3/ The recent story that those 'suspected' of being Israeli will be barred entry to the UAE was almost too comical to be true. Apparently now no matter what passport you're holding (even if its a real one), UAE Immigration will now be playing a game of 'Spot the Jew', based on such objective measures as accent and mannerisms. Perhaps they will be able to get some consultancy training from Borat...

Note: The satirist who plays Borat, the wonderfully talented Sasha Baron-Cohen, is very, very Jewish.

Here's the UAE official describing the new plan:
... "Earlier, Israeli dual citizens could easily enter the country even if officials recognised them as Israelis from their accents and traits," he said.
"But [from] now on they will be carefully scrutinised, regardless of what passport they hold."
The Dubai Police Chief added that this did not mean anyone would be mistreated. He said immigration officers are to undergo intensive training to study Israeli people and identify their traits, accents, body language and manners.

Of course, the issue of why a well known wanted terrorist and murderer was welcomed into the UAE in the first place has not been discussed. Naturally.

And we all know how critical the Arab world is on the general topic of immigration, travel and racial stereotyping at airports, as long as its the West we're criticising...

Ah well.

And as promised, that Stratfor Analysis.

"This report is republished with permission of STRATFOR"

Using Intelligence from the al-Mabhouh Hit
By Fred Burton and Ben West

The assassination of senior Hamas militant leader Mahmoud al-Mabhouh on Jan. 19 is still generating a tremendous amount of discussion and speculation some six weeks after the fact. Dubai’s police force has been steadily releasing new information almost on a daily basis, which has been driving the news cycle and keeping the story in the media spotlight. The most astounding release so far has been nearly 30 minutes of surveillance camera footage that depicts portions of a period spanning the arrival of the assassination team in Dubai, surveillance of al-Mabhouh, and the killing and the exfiltration of the team some 22 hours later.

By last count, Dubai police claim to have identified some 30 people suspected of involvement in the assassination; approximately 17 have been convincingly tied to the operation through video footage either as surveillants, managers or assassins, with the rest having only tenuous connections based on information released by the Dubai police. In any case, the operation certainly was elaborate and required the resources and planning of a highly organized agency, one most likely working for a nation-state.

While the 22-hour period depicted in the video showcased the tactical capabilities of the various teams, it hardly tells the whole story. In order to pinpoint the location of al-Mabhouh on the day of his killing, the organization responsible for this operation would have had to have tracked al-Mabhouh for months, if not years. This can be done in three ways: technical surveillance, utilization of human sources and physical surveillance.

Technical surveillance of al-Mabhouh would include monitoring his e-mail, telephone calls and other forms of electronic communications such as online credit-card transactions and travel reservations. This could reveal his physical location and future plans, which would allow the assassination team to anticipate his location and prepare well ahead of time. With such a large team involved in the assassination, careful coordination and planned movements would have been required to ensure that all members were in place without attracting attention.

But technical surveillance has limitations. An experienced operative like al-Mabhouh (who had been the target of two previous assassination attempts in as many years) would most likely have taken precautions that would have limited his electronic visibility. The operational team likely used human sources with close ties to al-Mabhouh who could corroborate the information and possibly influence the target’s movements, putting him in place for the operation. Human sources could have included al-Mabhouh’s colleagues within Hamas or a member of a rival group such as Fatah. (Three Palestinians suspected of being members of Fatah were arrested by Dubai authorities in connection with the assassination, indicating that the group may have provided human intelligence to the organization responsible for al-Mabhouh’s assassination.) Other people could have been recruited using a number of incentives (including cash) without their knowing the consequences of their assistance. Both the technical and human intelligence operations would have been run by intelligence officers operating abroad and at locations separate from the operational team.

According to Dubai police, physical surveillance was conducted by members of the operational team during al-Mabhouh’s previous trips to the United Arab Emirates. Physical surveillance is a critical part of any effective assault (whether it’s a clandestine intelligence operation or a car-jacking) because it gives the operatives an opportunity to become familiar with their surroundings and recognize their target in his or her “natural” environment.

Once all this homework was done to establish al-Mabhouh’s normal routines and determine his approximate location and duration of his stay in Dubai, the intelligence-collection process moved into the deployment phase and an operational team was sent into action.

The Operation
Prior to Mabhouh’s arrival, surveillance teams set up in the airport and at different hotels to make sure they could obtain a visual confirmation of their target. Based on their intelligence of his prior trips to Dubai, planners placed teams in two hotels to wait for al-Mabhouh approximately an hour before his arrival. They also had a surveillance team waiting for him at the airport to follow him as soon as he entered the country and report his movements to the rest of the team. While it wasn’t captured on video, we suspect that a mobile surveillance group tracked al-Mabhouh from the airport by car. To help ensure a successful outcome, the operational team used overwhelming force to prevent the target from ever seeing the same face twice. When it was established that al-Mabhouh was staying at the Al Bustan Rotana, the team responded by abandoning their other posts and directing their focus to that hotel.

Once al-Mabhouh was identified, the team locked on to him at the hotel and started initiating further steps in the operation. The first surveillance team watched al-Mabhouh register at the front desk and then followed him to his room, noting the target’s specific room number. This was relayed to other members of the team, who then placed a reservation for the room across the hall from al-Mabhouh, which gave them direct access to their target. The selection of the room is very interesting for two reasons. First, it was directly across the hall from al-Mabhouh’s room, giving the team a perfect spot from which to monitor his movements. Second, the room was just behind the video camera for that floor and the camera was trained on the emergency stairwell exit, which allowed the assassination team to carry out the attack on his room without being filmed.

Meanwhile, down in the hotel lobby, surveillance teams were rotating to monitor the target’s movements in and out of the hotel. At one point, a surveillant is seen following al-Mabhouh out to the street to relay by cell phone the type of vehicle he had entered. These surveillants, operating in teams of two, used disguises such as hats, sunglasses, beards and work-out gear to establish a cover for action and better conceal their identities. While many members of the operational team were identified on closed-circuit television (CCTV), hats and sunglasses helped distort their images and reduce the already low risk of being recognized by the target or any protective team during the operation.

Another necessity in any operation like this is communications. Surveillance video of the team involved in this operation shows them using cell phones to send text messages and talk to other members of the team. According to reports from Dubai police, the cell phones used in the operation were dialed to an Austrian number, likely the operations and support center for the team on the ground and any others involved in the operation. This might have been an open conference line into which all members of the operational team could dial to monitor the movement of their target. It is unlikely that the center was actually in Austria; it probably used a proxy phone line to mask its true physical location.

Assassination and Exfiltration
At approximately 8:30 p.m. on Jan. 19, after al-Mabhouh returned to his hotel room from a meeting, the assassination team moved in. It was important to carry out the killing at a time and in a manner that would give the team the maximum window of opportunity. They suspected that al-Mabhouh was in for the night, which meant that nobody would miss him until early the following afternoon, giving the team ample time to flee the country. The team carried out the assassination smoothly, with video surveillance showing only two operatives casually talking outside the elevator (a cover for monitoring the hall for possible distractions) — in other words, nothing out of the ordinary. The assassination team members also exhibited no unusual behavior when they departed the scene. Demeanor is extremely important, and the ability of the team to act calmly and naturally and not catch the attention of security guards monitoring CCTV ensured that the act remained a secret until hotel cleaning staff found the body more than 17 hours after the entire team had departed Dubai.

The assassination team also killed al-Mabhouh in a way that apparently confounded medical examiners trying to determine the cause of death, delaying the announcement of a criminal case for nine days. This delay gave the operational team ample time to cover its tracks, possibly by using third- and fourth-country border crossings, additional false identities and safe-houses, making it much harder for Dubai authorities to track team members to their ultimate destinations. This confusion appears to have been created by the use of a muscle relaxant called succinylcholine (also known as Suxamethonium), which, if used in large enough quantities, can cause the heart to stop, making it appear that the victim died of cardiac arrest. The drug also has a very short half-life, meaning that traces would degenerate and virtually disappear shortly after injection, making it ideal for covert operations such as this one.

The team was not able to pull off the operation with complete anonymity — it is virtually impossible to operate in a modern environment without leaving some kind of electronic trace. The Dubai police were able to use video surveillance from the airport, hotels and a nearby shopping center to trace back the movements of the operatives and establish their identities according to the passports that they used. These later proved to be fraudulent passports from the United Kingdom, Ireland, Germany and France — but they were extremely well-made fraudulent passports that were discovered later, only after video surveillance prompted closer scrutiny; customs officials were unable to detect this when the operatives were arriving or departing. Moreover, the credit cards used by several members of the operation team were linked to a company called Payoneer. The company’s CEO is a former member of Israel Defense Forces special operations, and Payoneer has financial backing from a company based in Israel.

Dubai police have announced that they retrieved DNA evidence from at least one of the members on the assassination team and fingerprints from several others, giving authorities pieces of evidence that are unalterable, unlike a passport. However, DNA evidence is only helpful when it can be compared against an exemplar. If Dubai police are unable to find a match to the DNA sample or a fingerprint, then these clues will offer little immediate help.

The passports also provide little immediate help in terms of tracking down the suspects. The discovery that fraudulent British, Irish, German and French passports were used has created a diplomatic problem for Israel (Mossad is understandably at the top of the list of suspects), which raises the profile of the operation considerably. This is certainly not what a clandestine operation is supposed to do. Although the operatives will probably never be found and handed over to UAE authorities, the fact that so many details of the assassination have been made public jeopardizes the anonymity that is supposed to surround this kind of operation.

Potential Consequences
Al-Mabhouh was hardly a likable character. As a senior Hamas military commander, arms smuggler and liaison to Iran, he was already on the terrorist watch lists in the countries that have complained about the use of fraudulent passports. Public indignation is a necessary and expected reaction from these countries to save diplomatic face, but when it comes down to it, there would be few incentives to seriously punish Israel, if it indeed sponsored the hit. The police of Dubai and the United Arab Emirates, rightfully frustrated that they are tasked with solving an unsolvable case, will still probably not miss al-Mabhouh. Their efforts to stir up outrage over the assassination are likely fueled by their desire to save face in the Arab world, where the Palestinian cause is of high rhetorical importance but little strategic importance.

The fact is that the high level of complexity involved in this assassination, along with the smoothness with which it was carried out, is evidence that the operation was undertaken by an elite covert force, the likes of which could only be sponsored by a nation-state. The ability to conduct preliminary intelligence collection, to muster a large and coordinated team of skilled operatives, to fabricate passports to an exacting degree, to successfully exfiltrate all members of the team — all of this requires a significant and well-funded effort that, we believe, exceeds the current capabilities of any non-state terrorist group. It is worth noting here that the most impressive aspect of the operation was the team’s tradecraft and demeanor. All the members of this team were professionals.

Indeed, with so much time having already elapsed, and if the operation was sponsored by a nation-state, it is highly improbable that any of the operatives involved will ever be caught. However, countries around the world are offering their assistance in the case, including the United Kingdom, the United States, Canada and Australia. Few officials from these countries actually believe any of the operatives will be apprehended, but that is not the real reason to participate in the investigation. What officials are really looking for are the granular details of how this group of assassins and surveillants operated. These details are extremely valuable in ongoing counterintelligence efforts by countries to thwart foreign intelligence agencies operating on their home turf. The information can provide clues to past and future cases, and it can be used to build databases on covert operatives, so that if any of these people show up unexpectedly at an airport, hotel or embassy in the United Kingdom, the United States, Canada, Australia or elsewhere, the alarms can be sounded more quickly.


  1. Paul Woodward argues that the increased scrutiny of traveling white folks might have negative consequences for the support of Israel by the West.

  2. ...Dubai Inc. is super pissed off at being shown to be a bit of a pussy and not a safe place for terrorists and arms dealers.

    That was hilarious!

    Good post.

    Seema Guha

  3. Racial profiling is not a good idea anywhere, but it is promoted everywhere these days, isn't it. Humanity is furiously back-pedaling.

  4. UD

    Please stop like the arabic saying go " mixing pioson with honey ". I think After Iraq war, no westrener with a decent IQ and education will use terrosit argument against the arabs. Look in mirror before typing bullshit that will get you in deep trouble and deported out of this country.

  5. Yaaaaaay UD!

    I know you came onto my blog complaining about me getting the best weirdos on the internet!

    But the above poster takes the cake in the "window licker" stakes.

    I particularly like:

    "Look in mirror before typing bullshit that will get you in deep trouble and deported out of this country."

    If I had a rial for everytime some moron said that to me, I'd have a Porsche Cayenne!

    The fact of the matter is that a lot of people in this world need to have a good long look in the mirror instead of getting their wizzars in a twist over being shown the facts.

    So where to next? I wonder will the racist card be played, or the culture one?

    One will wait with bated breath!

  6. Assalamu Aleikum!

    I just want to tell all of you Omanis and Expats alike how much I appreciate Oman for its tolerance of others. I am of Jewish heritage (I don't practice the religion) and have to say my experiences living in Oman have been nothing but positive. Most educated people I knew recognised from my name that I am Jewish and they had no problems with fact, it was a non issue. This goes to show you how much of a tolerant country HM has fostered. I met other Jews with similar positive experiences. Of course, we were mainly engaging with highly educated people, but the hospitality shown to me was overwhelming. I feel greatly at home in Oman. Many of my closest friends in Oman all know I am Jewish and they greet me with "Shalom"

    Living in Oman has given me a greater reverence for Islam and the Arabic culture (I took Arabic lessons). When I return to Europe, I tell people of my wonderful experiences here. I hope in my tiny way, I can serve as a positive ambassador for the relative peace and harmony that exists in Oman.

    Oman, you wil always have a special place in my heart. Shukran!

  7. i saw this and couldn't resist: mossad's operation dubai t-shirts!

    you think i'll get into trouble wearing one while paddling my kayak in and around dubai mall :) ?

  8. Dubai is a safe haven for all the terrorists and drug pushers, they operate with impunity.
    Dawood Ibrahim is a typical example, he controls one of the biggest drugs/ terrorist outfits in Asia and was seen moving around in the open in Dubai . He (and people like him) were forced to lower their profile a bit only after the 9/11. They are down, but not out and the powers be in Dubai are pissed off that some other govts are taking them out !!!
    Hope Mossad (or someone else) take out some more of these bastards holed up in Dubai, they deserve Nobel prize for getting rid of these scum.

  9. I like the quote -- Palestine is of rhetorical interest and not strategic. Very true. Most countries would love to wash their hands of this persistent problem.


If you wish to post anonymously, please pick a nickname by selecting the Name/URL option, or at least sign off your comment with one! I will delete comments I find objectionable or needlessly inflammatory. Sorry for the word verification.... OMG the spam has gotten BAD these past 12 months... trying to avoid making one log in...